Rainbow flag beside a marked document in an assembly hall, with an American flag and text reading “Our lives are not up for erasure.”

Podcast Episode: My Government Voted to Remove People Like Me From a UN Resolution on Unlawful Ki

Pip: Welcome back to The Babblings of JT — where the posts range from the personal to the political, and sometimes land somewhere that makes both categories feel inadequate.

Mara: JT Santana takes on something urgent this episode: a United Nations vote on unlawful killings, what the U.S. actually did, and why the distinction between a bad vote and the worst imaginable act still demands outrage. Let's start with the vote itself and what it means to have skin in the game.

My Government Voted to Remove People Like Me

Pip: The title alone does a lot of work. This is a post about a specific UN committee vote on November 13, 2026 — and about what it means when the government that represents you supports erasing you from a document about who gets killed and why.

Mara: The post is careful to draw the line precisely. "The United States did not vote to make murdering gay or transgender people legal. On November 13, 2026, in the UN General Assembly's Third Committee, the U.S. supported an unsuccessful amendment to delete explicit references to sexual orientation and gender identity from a resolution on extrajudicial, summary, or arbitrary executions."

Pip: So the amendment failed — 74 to 69, with 24 abstentions — and the language stayed in. That's the relief. But the post argues, hard, that falling short of the worst outcome is not the same as making a defensible choice.

Mara: Right. And the post names what was actually at stake: Egypt introduced the amendment on behalf of much of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, proposing to replace named identities with vague language about "circumstances placing people at heightened risk." Finland's representative pushed back, noting that erasing a group from the text would not erase its vulnerability.

Pip: The post uses a forensic argument to make this concrete. If a gay man received threats tied to his sexuality before he was killed, that context is evidence. Removing identity from the resolution doesn't make the investigation cleaner — it hands investigators a broken map.

Mara: Outright International's October 2026 report documented more than 230 targeted killings of LGBTIQ people between January 2020 and July 2026, while cautioning that verified cases represent only a fraction of the actual toll. The post treats that caveat seriously — an incomplete count shrinks a global crisis to fit available paperwork.

Pip: And there's a historical comparison that sharpens the accountability question. In December 2010, the U.S. led the effort to restore sexual orientation language after it had been stripped in committee — an amendment that passed 93 to 55. That precedent exists. Officials cannot claim they lacked a roadmap.

Mara: The post's demand for December's plenary vote is direct: the U.S. must support the resolution with explicit recognition intact, explain the November 13 position, and answer on the record. "Patriotism, as I understand it, means refusing to lower my standards just to make my government look better."

Pip: What holds the whole post together is the refusal to separate the personal from the evidential. Being furious and being accurate are not in conflict — and the post insists on both, loudly.

Mara: The closing argument is worth sitting with. "Nobody should have to be admirable, productive, respectable, or easy to like to deserve protection from unlawful killing." That's the floor, and the post argues the vote treated it as negotiable.

Pip: December's plenary is still ahead — which means the question this post raises isn't closed yet.


Mara: The thread running through this episode is accountability — what governments owe the people their decisions touch, and what happens when precision becomes an excuse for silence.

Pip: Next time, we'll see what else is on JT's mind. If this episode is any indication, it won't be small.

Leave a Reply