By JT Santana | jtwb768
I am a gay man, a father, and a grandfather. I have lived long enough to know that public acceptance can be conditional, that political promises can expire, and that people who speak warmly about freedom sometimes grow remarkably uncomfortable when someone else expects to enjoy it. None of that has prepared me to feel casual about my government supporting the removal of people like me from the explicit language of a United Nations resolution addressing unlawful killings.
Some stories I approach with a reporter’s curiosity; others, with a citizen’s concern. This one reaches somewhere far more personal—the part of me that is exhausted by the recurring suggestion that our lives require another debate, another qualification, another negotiation over whether naming the danger we face is asking too much.
Before going further, let’s keep the factual boundary clear. The United States did not vote to make murdering gay or transgender people legal. On November 13, 2026, in the UN General Assembly’s Third Committee, the U.S. supported an unsuccessful amendment to delete explicit references to sexual orientation and gender identity from a resolution on extrajudicial, summary, or arbitrary executions. The amendment failed 74–69 with 24 abstentions, and the committee approved the draft resolution with the language intact (Outright International, 2026b). That distinction deserves honesty, and the documented action deserves outrage.
I refuse to inflate the facts just to make them easier to condemn, and I refuse to let technical precision become an excuse for pretending those facts are harmless. An administration can make a morally appalling choice without signing a document that literally authorizes murder. Our standards should be higher than congratulating officials for stopping short of the worst imaginable act.
My anger is not a substitute for evidence. It is my response to the evidence—and I have no intention of dressing that response in language so polite that the betrayal disappears.
For me, the injury is personal without being exclusive. I am thinking about gay men who do not have the safety to put their names beneath an essay like this one. I am thinking about transgender people whose lives are treated as an ideological inconvenience, about partners whose grief is handled like an embarrassment, and about families who need a real investigation rather than an official explanation for why a victim’s identity is best left unmentioned.
I want a country that can recognize those people without flinching. I want representatives who can say that targeted violence demands attention without first checking whether acknowledging the target might irritate a political constituency. That is a modest expectation of a government that claims to champion human dignity, and I am furious that it has become an expectation I must defend.
My anger is not a substitute for evidence. It is my response to the evidence—and I have no intention of dressing that response in language so polite that the betrayal disappears.
What the Vote Did—and Why Precision Strengthens the Criticism
The November 13 vote took place in the General Assembly’s Third Committee, which handles social, humanitarian, and human rights issues. Egypt introduced the amendment on behalf of most members of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. The United States backed it, but the committee rejected the change and preserved the text (Outright International, 2026b).
Egypt’s proposal sought to replace named grounds with broader phrasing about circumstances placing people at heightened risk of unlawful execution, arguing that the existing terminology was disputed and obstructed consensus (Hands Off Cain, 2026). That is the actual issue at stake: whether a resolution on targeted killings should continue naming sexual orientation and gender identity among the grounds on which people are targeted.
Naming that distinction does not weaken the criticism; it pinpoints the decision that needs defending. If U.S. officials believe that replacing explicit recognition with a vague catch-all improves protection, they should explain how, present the evidence behind that assessment, and answer the people who would lose that recognition.
Speaking for the Nordic countries, Finland’s representative explained that the paragraph simply identifies groups exposed to unlawful killings and impunity, noting that erasing a group from the text would not erase its vulnerability and that the language reaffirms existing commitments rather than imposing new domestic legal requirements (Permanent Mission of Finland to the United Nations, 2026).
A document can affirm everyone’s humanity while still identifying specific patterns of violence. Those two functions reinforce each other: the universal principle establishes whose lives count, and the named categories show where that principle is failing in practice.
That observation exposes the dishonesty of framing this vote as a harmless editorial cleanup. A document can affirm everyone’s humanity while still identifying specific patterns of violence. Those two functions reinforce each other: the universal principle establishes whose lives count, and the named categories show where that principle is failing in practice.
Consider a hypothetical investigation involving a religious minority. If a victim received threats referencing their faith, investigators would have an obvious reason to examine religious hostility as a motive. A general assurance that all deaths matter would not tell anyone whether investigators actually pursued that lead.
Apply the same logic to a gay man whose attacker used threats targeting his sexuality. Identifying a possible bias motive does not predetermine guilt or elevate his life above anyone else’s. It opens a line of inquiry essential to solving the crime and preventing the next one.
These are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of specific cases, and they show why universal protection and attention to particular risks belong together. I do not need my government to endorse every detail of my life; I need it to stop treating the recognition of violence against people like me as a diplomatic inconvenience to be edited away.
I Know What It Means to Be Reduced to a Category
My life cannot be summed up by the single word gay. It encompasses parenthood, friendships, work, mistakes, responsibilities, faith, and the ordinary business of getting through a day. Yet that word belongs in any honest account of who I am, and I will not pretend it becomes irrelevant whenever acknowledging it makes an official uncomfortable.
Being a father and a grandfather does not make me more deserving of protection than a gay man without children, a transgender woman estranged from her family, or any queer person whose life looks nothing like mine. Those roles simply give me a personal point of entry into a larger question: what does a government owe the people whose lives its decisions touch?
When I read about someone who has been murdered, I resist the bureaucratic reduction that turns them into a demographic line item. That person had a voice, habits, unfinished arguments, a favorite meal, and plans that never became memories. No UN resolution can restore any of that, but the institutions responding to a death can at least refuse to make the victim invisible.
My background in nursing and my years caring for patients during the AIDS crisis shape how I read official language about dignity. Stigma is never an abstract concept for me; I associate it with the difference between seeing a patient’s clinical needs and allowing moral judgment to interfere with care. I am not equating a UN amendment with a bedside decision, but the underlying institutional failure is familiar: what happens when an authority sees a disfavored identity before it sees a human being.
Nobody should have to be admirable, productive, respectable, or easy to like to deserve protection from unlawful killing. My rights cannot depend on how closely I resemble the citizen an official would prefer me to be.
There is something deeply exhausting about having to present our humanity repeatedly, complete with supporting documentation. We point out that we have families, as if people without supportive families deserve less. We point out that we work, volunteer, and pay taxes, as if protection from violence were an employee benefit earned only after a satisfactory performance review.
I reject that entire bargain. Nobody should have to be admirable, productive, respectable, or easy to like to deserve protection from unlawful killing. My rights cannot depend on how closely I resemble the citizen an official would prefer me to be.
The people affected by this vote do not need an invitation to become human; they already are. A government’s obligation begins with that baseline fact, and my patience ends when acknowledging it becomes a negotiable concession.
I can write these words from Davenport with my name attached and my anger stated plainly. That security carries an obligation to look beyond my own front porch—to demand that the person who cannot safely speak receives the exact same recognition I am claiming here.
The 2010 Reversal Is More Than a Historical Footnote
Comparing this vote to 2010 matters for reasons deeper than partisan nostalgia. In December 2010, after sexual-orientation language had been stripped out in committee, the United States led the diplomatic effort in the General Assembly to put it back—an amendment that passed 93–55, with gender identity later added in 2012 (The White House, 2015).
That history provides concrete proof of a different American choice. The United States has the diplomatic weight to defend explicit recognition of people facing targeted violence, treating objections to naming them as obstacles to overcome rather than demands to accommodate.
Years of political organizing taught me what that distinction means on the ground. Asking people to trust public institutions requires real emotional investment—conversations, credibility, and the willingness to tell someone that civic participation might yield something worth having.
Recognizing the significance of the 2010 vote does not require pretending the Obama years were flawless. No administration earns immunity from scrutiny through a single good decision, and no political party holds a monopoly on compassion. Records must be judged decision by decision, especially when they involve communities with ample reason to distrust official promises.
The standard here is straightforward and nonpartisan: defending explicit recognition of people targeted for violence deserves support, and attempting to erase it deserves opposition, regardless of which administration casts the vote.
This reversal stings precisely because a better precedent is already on the books. Officials cannot claim they lacked a roadmap when a previous American government faced a comparable dispute and decided that naming those at risk was worth the fight.
Patriotism, as I understand it, means refusing to lower my standards just to make my government look better. I can love this country and condemn what its representatives do.
That leaves the current administration with an accountability problem. It owes the public a substantive explanation for reversing course. Responding with hostility toward terminology leaves the central question untouched: how does deleting those words improve the safety or treatment of people targeted because of who they are?
We should press that question without letting the conversation drift into unrelated culture-war distractions. A resolution on unlawful executions does not become a referendum on every controversy involving sex or gender merely because those words appear in the text. Officials should answer for the vote they cast.
Patriotism, as I understand it, means refusing to lower my standards just to make my government look better. I can love this country and condemn what its representatives do—and knowing it can act differently is precisely why I refuse to treat this vote as inevitable.
Naming the Violence Is Part of Taking It Seriously
The evidentiary case for explicit recognition stands firmly on its own. In an October 2026 report, Outright International documented more than 230 targeted killings of LGBTIQ people between January 2020 and July 2026 across detailed country studies, while cautioning that these verified cases represent only a fraction of the global toll (Outright International, 2026a).
That caveat matters. A documented tally shows what researchers could verify through accessible records; it does not mean every other killing was properly identified, investigated, or reported. Treating an incomplete count as a comprehensive total would distort the research and shrink a global crisis to fit the available paperwork.
The UN Special Rapporteur’s 2024 report makes a parallel investigative point: authorities must identify relevant motives and patterns of violence—including institutional failures and violence within families and communities—to investigate and prevent unlawful deaths effectively (Tidball-Binz, 2024). Recognizing a victim’s identity is not a ceremonial courtesy; it is a forensic necessity.
Picture a hypothetical transgender woman who reports threats tied to her identity and is later killed. Those earlier threats are directly relevant evidence; a competent investigation must test that connection rather than brushing it aside as politically inconvenient. Or consider a gay man subjected to extortion over his sexuality: that vulnerability may explain how a perpetrator gained access to him, controlled him, or silenced potential witnesses. Erasing that context leaves investigators with a broken map of the crime.
None of this assumes that every killing of an LGBTQ+ person is a bias crime—an assumption no serious writer or investigator should make. It simply keeps a crucial investigative avenue open when the facts warrant it.
Public commentary requires that same discipline. I should never label an unexplained death a hate crime without evidence, repeat unverified claims, or flatten an individual into a talking point. My job is to state what is established, acknowledge what remains uncertain, and resist official language that makes relevant facts disappear.
The moral imperative and the evidentiary imperative point to the exact same conclusion: honor the whole person, investigate the circumstances honestly, and hold perpetrators accountable on the facts. Nothing about that process improves when an identity becomes too controversial to name.
My Faith Does Not Require Anyone Else’s Erasure
My relationship with faith is personal, and I take it seriously. I do not view Christianity as an excuse to ration my concern for people whose lives look different from mine. If faith adds anything meaningful to a public debate, it should sharpen my attention to suffering and hold me to a stricter standard of moral consistency.
I do not need every religious believer to agree with me about sexuality, but I do expect a clear line between theological disagreement and the refusal to acknowledge targeted violence. Someone can hold traditional religious convictions and still insist that threats be investigated, victims be recognized, and perpetrators face justice.
That expectation applies across every faith tradition and to those with no religious belief at all. Egypt’s sponsorship of the amendment does not justify blaming Muslims collectively for a diplomatic maneuver, just as U.S. support does not make every Christian complicit. Criticism loses its moral footing the moment it trades accountability for specific officials for broad contempt toward entire populations.
My dispute is with governments—what their representatives endorsed, what rationale they offered, and what consequences they were willing to accept. Assigning collective guilt by religion would replicate the exact habit of erasure I am opposing.
Before the vote, a coalition of civil-society organizations emphasized that the resolution creates no hierarchy among victims and establishes no new rights; its purpose is strictly to ensure effective investigation and accountability, including for identity-linked killings (Human Rights Watch, 2026).
We do not need consensus on marriage, scripture, or the vocabulary of identity before agreeing that an unlawful killing demands a competent investigation. Making ideological agreement a prerequisite turns basic human protection into a reward for conformity.
People with profound disagreements ought to be able to stand behind that principle. We do not need consensus on marriage, scripture, or the vocabulary of identity before agreeing that an unlawful killing demands a competent investigation. Making ideological agreement a prerequisite turns basic human protection into a reward for conformity.
I have little patience for religious rhetoric that grows most elaborate at the exact moment simple compassion is required—or for secular evasions that swap theology for talk of tradition, sovereignty, or consensus to dodge the same question. A grieving family does not need a lecture on how a victim’s identity complicates a diplomat’s talking points.
Anger Has to Become a Demand for Accountability
Defeating the amendment in committee was a relief, not a resolution. The draft still moves to the full General Assembly plenary in December, where opponents can try again to strip the language (Outright International, 2026b). Holding the line in committee means very little if the text is gutted on the floor.
The immediate demand is clear: the United States must support the resolution in December with explicit recognition intact. The administration should explain its November 13 vote, identify who authorized that position, and state plainly how it will vote in the plenary. Members of Congress should press for those answers on the record.
Citizens can make that demand just as directly. Contact your representatives and ask whether they support keeping explicit references to sexual orientation and gender identity in the UN resolution on unlawful killings. Ask them to seek a formal explanation from the administration—and insist on a substantive, written answer rather than a boilerplate platitude about respecting all Americans.
Journalists carry a parallel responsibility. Headlines claiming the U.S. voted to legalize murder hand officials an easy straw man to knock down, while coverage that buries the attempted deletion under dry procedural jargon disguises a major policy reversal as routine housekeeping. Readers deserve reporting that states the action plainly and asks the hard follow-ups: why was explicit recognition unacceptable, what evidence backed removing it, and how did U.S. diplomats weigh the warnings from human rights monitors and allied nations?
Those of us with a public platform also owe it to the people at greatest risk not to turn their lives into props for our own outrage. Their names, relationships, and circumstances deserve care. Anger should spotlight failures of protection and accountability rather than turning someone else’s death into stagecraft.
We need a standard that outlives this news cycle and applies regardless of who holds power: whenever officials propose deleting a named group from a measure addressing targeted harm, ask what problem that deletion actually solves, whose evidence was consulted, and whether the people in danger were treated as human beings or political inconveniences.
I Will Not Apologize for Taking This Personally
Whenever people whose dignity has been put up for public debate express anger, a familiar chorus tells them to calm down, be reasonable, and stop taking it personally. I am entirely capable of being reasonable. I have checked the record, separated the proposed edit from its legal effect, and refused to accuse my government of actions the evidence does not support.
I am tired of the notion that emotional distance is the price of admission for credibility. A person can be furious and accurate. A person can feel betrayed and still distinguish cleanly between evidence, interpretation, and fear.
Taking this personally is not a flaw in my reasoning; it is the simple recognition that the category on the chopping block includes lives like mine. There is no intellectual virtue in pretending I have no stake in whether public institutions consider violence against gay people worth naming.
I am tired of the notion that emotional distance is the price of admission for credibility. A person can be furious and accurate. A person can feel betrayed and still distinguish cleanly between evidence, interpretation, and fear.
We deserve better than a political culture that forces citizens to prove an action is the worst possible atrocity before permitting them to condemn it. A government does not have to authorize murder for its choices to warrant fierce opposition. Attempting to erase explicit recognition of people targeted for violence is a grave failure on its own terms.
I keep thinking about what I want my grandchildren to learn from how I meet this moment. I want them to see that accuracy is a moral duty, especially when the facts confirm our anger. I want them to see that basic decency requires more than liking people, and that citizenship means challenging officials who act in our name.
Most of all, I want them to know that a person’s safety should never depend on becoming familiar or agreeable enough to satisfy those in power—not here, and not for someone living across an ocean, speaking another language, practicing another faith, or loving someone their neighbors condemn.
I cannot promise that every government will meet that standard, but I can insist that mine be judged by it. Lowering the bar does not erase the failure; it only makes us complicit in overlooking it.
December’s plenary vote offers a clear choice. The United States can defend explicit recognition, account for its committee vote, and stand with the people whose vulnerability made that language necessary in the first place. Until it does, my criticism stands. I am a gay American who expects his government to recognize the humanity of people like him—including those who will never have the safety to speak for themselves. I am fucking livid that this expectation requires another defense, and I intend to keep
